The guys BROUGHT it!
Well, we made it! Today we meet the
first half of the top 24! Man I wish I could have some popcorn…. Lol Its going
to be good! Get prepared!! Below you will find my rating about each Idol
singer. Tonight is the top 12 guys.
I have decided that this season I
will watch the show and judge without the imput of the judges. I mute them
while I type my results. Then I replayed the results during breaks and said who
I agreed with. Honestly!! These performances are in order so if you are still
up until 12:00 PM EST tonight, you can still call in! Remember the number is
1-866-IDOLS(43657)-(their two digits eg. 01 or 12) OR if you have a AT&T
Wireless phone, you can text the word VOTE to 57(their two digits). ((OK now I
really feel like Ryan))
01. David Hernandez sang In
the Midnight Hour.
How I think they did: He did a great job with the song. Had some definite pitch
problems but for being the first person up, he did great! He needed to move
around a bit.
I agree with Randy and Simon on
replay.
My Order (This week: -) (Last week:
-)
02. Chikeze Eze sang More
Today Than Yesterday.
How I think they did: It was just OK for me. I thought it was pitchy towards
the beginning. I really like his
personality (because he fought back against Simon)
I agree with, more or less Simon, on
replay.
My Order (This week: -) (Last week:
-)
03. David Cook sang Happy
Together by The Turtles.
How I think they did: It started out weird, I couldn’t really pick out what
song it was, but once he got into it, it ROCKED! Best performance of the night
so far.
I agree with Randy on replay.
My Order (This week: -) (Last week:
-)
04. Jason Yeager sang Moon
River.
How I think they did: There were some
pitch problems… I couldn’t really figure out what song he was singing… It was
actually kind of weird because I lost track of what he was saying half way thru
the song. I’m going to use Simon’s F word… FORGETTIBLE
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: -) (Last week:
-)
05. Robbie Carrico sang One
by Three Dog Night.
How I think they did: It was really good, but I don’t think he’ll be able to
sing anything else. He may make it to the top 12 but he’ll turn out like
Daughtry. He says he can sing anything but time will tell.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: -) (Last week:
-)
06. David Archuleta sang Shop
Around by Smokey Robinson & the Miracles.
How I think they did: Wow. I couldn’t believe how AMAZING that was. DEFINITLY
will make it to the top 12.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: -) (Last week:
-)
07. Danny Noriega sang Jailhouse
Rock by Elvis Presley.
How I think they did: It was fairly good. Not my favorite of the night… Way too safe.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: -) (Last week:
-)
08. Luke Menard sang Everybody’s
Talking.
How I think they did: Not my favorite, very pitchy. Especially right at the
end. It didn’t work for me.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: -) (Last week:
-)
09. Colton Berry sang Suspicious
Minds by Elvis Presley.
How I think they did: it was OK, not as bad as some of the others. Wasn’t on
the top of his game.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: -) (Last week:
-)
10. Garrett Haley (from OH!!) sang
Breaking Up is Hard to Do by Neil Sedaka.
How I think they did: It was a great song but it was BORING.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: -) (Last week:
-)
11. Jason Castro sang Daydream
by The Lovin’ Spoonful.
How I think they did: Had a few pitch
problems but overall, really well done.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: -) (Last week:
-)
12. Michael Johns sang Light
My Fire by The Doors.
How I think they did: That was really
really good!
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: -) (Last week:
-)
WOW, the guys BROUGHT it tonight! I
did not number them this week just because it was simply too hard to put a
number to these guys so far. I hope the gals work even harder to bring it
tomorrow!